Image by Getty Images via Daylife
Thoughts on this post began with an website called The Conference Board. Quote: Citizenship and sustainability - sometimes referred to as corporate social responsibility - are new business realities. In today's marketplace, companies wishing to improve their long-term competitiveness, profitability, and market valuation must be effective in integrating citizenship and sustainability into core business strategy. Markets, customers, regulators, Boards, and society-at-large are demanding it.
I had never given much thought to corporate citizenship before. The phrase, "society-at-large...[is]demanding it." caught my eye. For some reason an op-ed piece I had seen in the Oregonian about the Whole Food boycott popped into my mind. Could it be that the controls that society-at large-place on corporations is also spilling over onto the personal opinions of their CEO's? I think the answer is probably yes. Here is my op-od opinions on the Whole Food's boycott.
In a recent ob-ed piece published in the The Oregonian called
Misguided boycott of Whole Foods maligns CEO, imperils rights, Amanda Moll spoke out against the consumer boycott of
Whole Foods. If you will recall, the owner of Whole Foods had an opinions on Health Care reform and stated it publicly in the
Wall Street Journal. The article lays out a long list of solutions for the problems in the health care system, all well thought out and logical in their approach. I was very impressed and wish with all my heart that the system could be fix in the piece meal fashion
John Mackey suggested.
His contention that we needed to reform
Medicare was a real hot button issue and one that caused consumer confidence to fall during the Bush administration. Then at the end of the article that he got himself in trouble. The last few paragraphs just did not sit well with people. They did not like the idea that many health issues the American people face could be self-inflicted.
Unfortunately many of our health-care problems are self-inflicted: two-thirds of Americans are now overweight and one-third are obese. Most of the diseases that kill us and account for about 70% of all health-care spending—heart disease, cancer, stroke, diabetes and obesity—are mostly preventable through proper diet, exercise, not smoking, minimal alcohol consumption and other healthy lifestyle choices.
Recent scientific and medical evidence shows that a diet consisting of foods that are plant-based, nutrient dense and low-fat will help prevent and often reverse most degenerative diseases that kill us and are expensive to treat. We should be able to live largely disease-free lives until we are well into our 90s and even past 100 years of age.
The writer in the op-ed piece for the Oregonian here in Portland, Oregon felt that the boycott threatened John Mackey's freedom of speech rights and might in fact muzzle other business owners rights to expressing their opinions in public. In her article Moll contended that by boycotting Whole Foods we were somehow infringing on the freedom of speech rights of Mackey. When consumers began calling for his removal from the Whole Food chain of command she felt the consumers had overstepped the bounds and squelched Mackey's conservative voice. She said:
This isn't about the bucks, but about ideology. This isn't about removing Mackey because he hurt business, but because he doesn't toe the liberal line.
Does the consumer really have the right or even the power to dictate who is leading companies? And, if they do, how can they go about acting on those rights? I don't necessarily agree with Mackey nor do I agree with Amanda Moll. In my opinion the only way we can counteract the voice of someone as important or with as big a soap box ad John Mackey is to hurt them or the company they work for financially. In the same way we support workers from the United State by not buying things produced in China, we can support the American people's right to enjoy the same health care benefits as those enjoyed by public servants and our nations representatives by choosing where we spend our money. Health care may not be our right but we certainly have the right to spend what we earn where and when we want. As every Republican Conservative knows...MONEY TALKS!!!
I might add that CEO's are much like public servants. While we all have a
right to voice our opinions, our jobs place certain boundaries on what we say. It is sad but very, very true. When Mackey decided to put his views on public display he lost his right to protections from public opinion. It is just unfortunate that the business he runs suffers too. Maybe he is learning a lesson in the true meaning of "freedom of speech"...that he is not the only one with a very big voice!!!
Just a thought.
b
Oh by the way, if Amanda Moll is wondering, I use only one paper towel to dry my hands. Resources are not MINE to waste! I just thought she would want to know.